MISTAKE IN THE EXPLANATION OF HADITH OF BANI ISHAQ

baniishaq

Mistake in explanation of Hadith telling about Muslim Army from Childern of Prophet Ishaq (Alayhay salam) helping Jesus and attacking Constantinople

Click to HOME PAGE

Muslim Israelis, Muslim Arabs,Prophet Jeus, Imam Mahdi and the final Battle between Muslims and Non Muslims

Muslims from Bani Ishaq and the Conquest of Constantinople at the time of Imam Mahdi and Prophet Jesus

1- Abu Huraira reported Allah's Apostle (may peace he upon him) saying: You have heard about a city the one side of which is in the land and the other is in the sea (Constantinople). They said: Allall's Messenger, yes. There upon he said: The Last Hour would not come unlesss seventy thousand persons from Bani lshaq would attack it. When they would land there, they will neither fight with weapons nor would shower arrows but would only say:" There is no god but Allah and Allah is the Greatest," that one side of it would fall. Thaur (one of the narrators) said: I think that he said: The part by the side of the ocean. Then they would say for the second time:" There is no god but Allah and Allah is the Greatest" that the second side would also fall, and they would say:" There is no god but Allah and Allah is the Greatest," that the gates would be opened for them and they would enter therein and, they would be collecting spoils of war and distributing them amongst themselves that a noise would be heard and It would be said: Verily, Dajjal has come. And thus they would leave everything there and would turn to him. (Reference Book 041, Number 6979: Saheh Muslim)

This hadith clearly tells that non Arab Muslims from the family of Prophet Ishaq will conquer Constantinople and not the Arab Muslims who belong to the family of Prophet Ismael(Alayhay Salam)

Mistake No-1 in the Explanation of the Hadith telling that Bani Ishaq means Bani Ismael

Some scholars are of the opinion that here the Word Bani Ishaq actually means Bani Ismael.This is not possible because of the following reasons mentioned in the ahadith given below.

Please check the mention of Constantinople again in the following hadith

2- Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: The Last Hour would not come until the Romans would land at al-A'maq or in Dabiq. An army consisting of the best (soldiers) of the people of the earth at that time will come from Medina (to counteract them). When they will arrange themselves in ranks, the Romans would say: Do not stand between us and those (Muslims) who took prisoners from amongst us. Let us fight with them; and the Muslims would say: Nay, by Allah, we would never get aside from you and from our brethren that you may fight them. They will then fight and a third (part) of the army would run away, whom Allah will never forgive. A third (part of the army). which would be constituted of excellent martyrs in Allah's eye, would be killed and the third who would never be put to trial would win and they would be conquerors of Constantinople. And as they would be busy in distributing the spoils of war (amongst themselves) after hanging their swords by the olive trees, the Satan would cry: The Dajjal has taken your place among your family. They would then come out, but it would be of no avail. And when they would come to Syria, he would come out while they would be still preparing themselves for battle drawing up the ranks. Certainly, the time of prayer shall come and then Jesus (peace be upon him) son of Mary would descend and would lead them in prayer. When the enemy of Allah would see him, it would (disappear) just as the salt dissolves itself in water and if he (Jesus) were not to confront them at all, even then it would dissolve completely, but Allah would kill them by his hand and he would show them their blood on his lance (the lance of Jesus Christ). (Book 041, Number 6924,SAHEEH MUSLIM)

Note: Both the Ahadith shows a common thing that they would hear a noise saying:Verily, Dajjal has come. And thus they would leave everything there and would turn to him.in both ahadith AND riThey would be conqueres of Constantinoplel in the 2nd hadith clearly shows that both the ahadith mention a same event.

Ahadith mentioning "The Small Number" of Arabs" at the time of Conquest of Constantinople

3- Umm Sharik reported: I heard Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: The people would run away from the Dajjal seeking shelter in the mountains. She said: Where would be the Arabs then in that day? He said: They would be small in number.( Reference : Saheeh Muslim Book 041, Number 7035).

4- The same hadith has been narrated on the authority of Ibn Juraij with the same chain of transmitters.( Reference : Saheeh Muslim ,Book 041, Number 7036 )

5- Hazrat Abu Qutada(R.A) narrated a long Hadith from Dear Prophet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) where Umm Sharik said: Where would be the Arabs then in that day?(Meaning why the Arabs wont come forward and fight for Islam ). He(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said: They would be small in number? And from that remaning Arabs,most of them will be in Bait-ul-Muqaddas (Sham) and their leader will be a pious man (Mahdi).When their leader will move forward to lead the Morning prayers,then,Hazrat Eisa(Alayhay salam) will descend from the sky.The leader will step back so that Hazrat Eisa(Alayhay salam) will lead the prayers but Hazrat Eisa(Alayhay salam) will put his hand on his back between his shoulders and say Move forward and lead the prayers because the Aqamah was called for you.Then the Imam will lead the prayers to all people. (Reference : Sunan Abi Majah ,307,308)

Note: The 5th Hadith shows that Hadith Number 3,4 and 5 mentions the same time and the Army of Islam as mentioned in Hadith 1 and 2 when they conquer Constantinople and come back to Sham.

IN SHORT ALL THE ABOVE 5 MENTIONED AHADITH ARE CO RELATED SO WE NOW WE CAN WRITE THE CHAIN OF EVENTS AS BELOW:

a : Muslims will fight with the Romans (Europeans or Christians) who will demand for their men among Muslims who became reverted to Islam and a fight will start where only 1/3rd of the Muslim armies will be left after victory.

b : The above 1/3rd victorious army will come to Sham where Prophet Jesus (Hazrat Eisa Alayhay salam) will join them.

c: In sham with this 1/3rd army there will be also a Small Number of Arabs or Bani Ismael.

d: A large number of army from these Muslims belonging to the Bani Ishaq will conquer Constantinople (base of Christians). After they conquer it Dajjal (Anti Christ) will come.

Explanation from the 5 ahadith for the meaning of 70,000 Bani Ishaq

70 THOUSAND ALWAYS MEANS A MAJORITY

The word 70 thousand always means a majority in the ahadith and according to the hadith number 3 ,4 and 5 the Arabs would be "Small in number" therefore 70,000 can never mean the Arabs / Bani Ismael.

How is it possible that the word "LESS" is used for the Arabs and even then people insist on calling th 70,000 Bani Ishaq as the Arabs???????

The word قليل in the hadith narrated by Umm Shuraik means a "very small number" and the word " 70 thousand" always means a vast majority in ahadith

Check the complete hadith telling that the Arabs will be in very small number

• Umm Sharik reported: I heard Allah's Messenger (Salallaho alayhay wa sallam) as saying: The people would run away from the Dajjal seeking shelter in the mountains. She said: Where would be the Arabs then in that day? He said: They would be very few. Reference : Saheeh Muslim Book 041, Number 7035

‏حدثني ‏ ‏هارون بن عبد الله ‏ ‏حدثنا ‏ ‏حجاج بن محمد ‏ ‏قال قال ‏ ‏ابن جريج ‏ ‏حدثني ‏ ‏أبو الزبير ‏ ‏أنه سمع ‏ ‏جابر بن عبد الله ‏ ‏يقول أخبرتني ‏ ‏أم شريك ‏
‏أنها سمعت النبي ‏ ‏صلى الله عليه وسلم ‏ ‏يقول ‏ ‏ليفرن الناس من ‏ ‏الدجال ‏ ‏في الجبال قالت ‏ ‏أم شريك ‏ ‏يا رسول الله فأين ‏ ‏العرب ‏يومئذ قال هم قليل صحيح مسلم

When Umm e Shuraik asked " Where would be the Arabs on that day?" that means that Why the Arabs wont fight Dajjal" Now if the Arabs are Very few to fight Dajjal (the Jewish King) then which Nation among Muslims will make the Majority of the Army of Mahdi

Prophet Jesus (Hazrat Eisa Alayhay salam) is also from Bani Ishaq

Prophet Hazrat Eisa alayhay Salam (i.e Prophet Jesus Christ )will be sent by Allah to help Mahdi and Prophet Hazrat Eisa is also from Bani-Ishaq /Bani-Israel. I hope they don’t change Hazrat Eisa(alayhay salam) to be among the Bani-Ismael.

It is strange that the hadith cleary use the word Bani Ishaq and not Bani Ismael. Also Prophet Jesus is from Bani Ishaq then why saying that Bani Ishaq points out to the Bani Ismael?????

This fact also proves that the BANI-ISHAQ written in the hadith means BANI-ISHAQ and not Bani Ismael since a prophet always comes among his own NATION at the beginning.

MORE AHADITH GIVING MORE EXPLANATION TO THE ARMY OF MAHD AND PROPHET JESUS (ALAY HAY SALAM)

MADHI’S FORCES WILL ALSO COME FROM EAST(Like some of the the Dajjal also and that’s one of the illusions)

6- Thawban (R.A) reported that Dear Propet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said, “ In your old age three men will be killed . Each of them will be the son of a Khalifah. Then the black banners will come out of the east, *1 and they will slaughter you in a way that no Nation has ever done before.Then Dear Prophet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said soemthing that I didn’t remember.Then again Dear Prophet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said if you see him give him your allegiance, even if you have to crawl over ice, because he is the Khalifah of Allah, the Mahdi.*2

7. Narrated by Hazrat Abu Huraira(radi Allah Anho) from Hazrat Abu Qatada:

Dear Prophet (Salallaho alayahy wa sallam) said: People will be given allegiance (Beyat) to person (i.e Mahdi) between the Ruken(Hajr-e-Aswad) and Mukam(Mukam-e-Ebraheem) and no one else but the same people who are related to that place(citizens of Makkah) will destroy the respect of Kabah(as they will attack Mahdi in Kabah where fighting is forbidden) and when they will declare it Halal then do not ask about the killing of the ARABS(there will be a mass killing of arabs).Then Ethopians(Africans) will come and they will desolate it in such a way that it would never be a habitat and these will be the people who will take out its treasure.*3

8. Narrated by Hazrat Abdullah Bin Masood(raddi Allah anho) that Dear Propher (salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said: A Nation will come from the East with Black Flags and they will ask for some “Khair” (because of them being needy) but the people will not give them,then,they will fight and win over those people(who didn’t give them what they asked).Now the people will give them what they asked for but they will not accept it untill they will hand it over to a person from my progeny who will fill this earth with Justice just as it was previoulsy filled with opression and tyranny .So if anyone of you find this Nation( i. e from the East with black flags) then you must joing them even if you have to crawl over ice.*4

References / Notes *1 This East is different from the NEJD and IRAQ as mentioned in other ahadith(written in the end here) telling that every Fitna (affliction) will appear from NEJD (and also in some ahadith Iraq is mentioned). *2 Reference Ibne Majah Page 300, Also in Ahmad's Musnad, al-Haakim's Mustadrak and others.). *3 Refernce :Masnad Imam Ahmad 35/15. Also Mustadrik J5 Page 456. *4 Reference Al-Asha-ah الآﺸﺍﻋﺔ Page 240. Also at Pag 108 in the book “Islam main Imam Mahdi ka Tasawer” by Maulana Professor Muhammad Yousaf Khan from Internationally acclaimed Islamic Insititution i.e Jamia Ashrafia Lahore,Pakistan.

More Ahadith about Bani Ishaq=Bani Israel = Al E Haroon

9. Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said: "He will be from my progeny and will be forty years of age. His face will shine like a star and he will have a black spot on his left cheek. He will don two "Qutwaani" cloaks and will appear exactly as a person from the Bani Israel."*1

10. Hadrat Abdullah bin Masud narrates………..then an Army of Liberated Slaves *2 will come to help Arabs(against the Romans) and say”O Arabs leave prejidice or no one will support you and there will be a war with the Idolaters……(The hadith continues) *3

11. Narrated Hazrat Umama reported Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said: You and the Romans(Christians) will have four peace treaties *4. The fourth peace would be at the hand of a person who would be from the Al-e-Haroon( family of Prophet Haroon).This peace treaty would be for seven years. Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) was asked who would be the Imam of the Muslims at that time. Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said” That person would be from my family,his age would be 40 years ,his face would be bright as a start and a black spot would be on his right cheek.He would be wearing two Qutwani Cloaks.He will appear exactly as the person from Bani Israeel. He will rule for 20 years and will conquer the cities of the Mushrikeen(Idolaters) *5

Reference/Notes *1 Reference : TabraniJamia Kabeer By Imam Suyuti)(also mentioned in EIHTESAAB-E QADIYANIAT Vol4 by Maulana Syed Badar Alam Merthi published by International Therik-e-Khatem-e-Nabowat). *2 Note : Bani Israel had been under slavery in Egypt and thus The Liberated Slaves means Bani Israel as the Israeli Language was also known as the Language of the slave. *3 Reference :Jamia Kabeer By Imam Suyuti .Also mentioned in EIHTESAAB-E QADIYANIAT Vol4 by Maulana Syed Badar Alam Merthi published by International Therik-e-Khatem-e-Nabowat). *4 Note :The following Hadith from Bokhari tells us about these Peace Treaties and thus further authenticates this Hadith. Auf bin Malik radhiyallahu anhu says: I came to Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam while he was in his skin tent during the Tabuk expedition. He said to me, "Count six things before the advent of Qiyamah: a.) My death b.) The conquest of Jerusalem c.) Mass deaths amongst you people, just as when sheep die in large numbers during an epidemic d.) Abundance of wealth to such an extent that if a person were to be given a hundred Dinars he will still not be satisfied e.) General Afflictions and bloodshed, that no Arab household will be spared from it . Then a life of peace as a result of a peace agreement between you and the Banil Asfaar (Romans) which they will break and attack you with a force consisting of eighty flags and under each flag will be an army of twelve thousand men." (Ref: Bokhari) *5 (Ref: Kanz-ul-Aamal, Page 268, Hadith No 3868).This hadith proves that the Saheeh Muslim hadith(No4 above) means Bani-Ishaq as Al-e-Haroon and Bani-Israel have the same meaning as Bani-Ishaq.

Ahadith mentioning the Khorasan(The land of the rising sun or The EAST).

12. Dear Prophet Muhammad(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said that”When you hear the news of Black Flags coming from the East, then, you must join them even if you have to crawl over ice(to reach them).*1

13. "Thawbaan reported that the Prophet (Sallallaahu `alayhi wa sallam) said, 'Three will fight for the your treasure (of the Ka`bah), each of them the son of a 'Khaleefah', it will be rendered to none of them. Then from the direction of the East will emerge Black Flags. Then they will fight you like they have fought none before.' Then some words were spoken which I did not remember. He then said, 'If you see him, give bay`ah to him even if you must crawl over ice. For, verily, he is the 'Khaleefah' of Allah (Khaleefatullaah), the Mahdi" *2

14- Thoban r.a(Companion of Dear Prophet Muhammad Salallaho alayhay wa sallam) reported that Dear Prophet Muhammad Salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said: When u see that Black Flags have appeared from KHORASAN ,go to (join) them as the Khalifah of Allah MAHDI will be among them *3

15- Abu Hurairah (R.A.) says that Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said: "(Armies carrying) black flags will come from Khorasan. No power will be able to stop them and they will finally reach Eela (Baitul Maqdas) where they will erect their flags."*4

16- Hadhrat Buraidah (R.A.) says that Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said: "There will be many armies after me. You must join that army which will come from Khorasan.*5

17- Narrated by Hazrat Abdullah bin Haris(R.A) that Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) said that “People will come from the East who will make Khilafah (Islamic Rule) easy for Imam Mahdi.*6

18 - Narrated by Abdur Rehman Al-Jarshi that I heard companion of Dear Prophet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam), Hazrat Amr Bin Marra Al-jamli(R.A) that Dear Prophet(salallaho alayhay wa sallam) said: Surely Black Flag will appear from the Khorasan until the people(under the leadership of this flag) will tie their horses with the Olive Trees between Bait-e-Lahya and Harasta. We asked are there any Olive trees between these places. He said,”If there isn’t then soon it will grow so that those people(of Khorasan) will come and tie their horses there.”*7

References /Notes *1 Ref: Saheeh Trimdi J2,Page 56. *2 Ref :Ibn Maajah, Ahmad's Musnad, al-Haakim's Mustadrak and others. *3 Ref: Baiqahee and Ahmed in Dalael-e-Nabowat ,Hadith No 5225 in Mishkat-ul-Masabeeh *4 Ref: Saheeh Trimdi *5 Ref: Narrated by Ibn-e-Adi & Asaker & Seyuti in Jamiah Sagheer .Also in http://www.islam.tc/prophecies/imam.html *6 Ref : Ibn-e-Majah Hadith 4088 *7 Ref: Kitab-al-Fitan Page 215. Also at Page 108 in the book “Islam main Imam Mahdi ka Tasawer” by Maulana Professor Muhammad Yousaf Khan,Jamia Ashrafia Lahore,Pakistan.

Khorasan means the Land from where the Sun rises. In other words it also means the EAST. So in the hadith ( Mentioned in Ibn Maajah, Ahmad's Musnad, al-Haakim's Mustadrak) the word EAST means the same as KHORASAN.

KHORASAN=THE EAST

Also one more fact that both the ahadith does not contradict each other is that land of KHORASAN is also in the EAST.So the word EAST actually points out to Khorasan.

Boundaries of Khorasan:

According to the reference from the wicked(i.e Britannica 1997):

KHURASAN,. The historical region extended, along the north, from the Amu Darya (OxusRiver) westward to the Caspian Sea and, along the south, from the fringes of the central Iranian deserts eastward to central Afghanistan. Arab geographers even spoke of its extending to the boundaries of India.

This definition tells that the following area is included in the Historical region of Ancient Khorasan.

· Northern Part of Iran ,

· Afghanistan,

· North Western Part of Pakistan and

· Southern parts of Central Asian Turkish states like Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan.

MORE EXPLANATION AND CONCLUSIONS

Arabs (Bani Ismael ) dont live in the East

Hadith 6, 7 and 8 tells that armies helping Mahdi and Jesus will come from the East and Arabs dont live in the East of Madina or Makkah .

How is it possible that Bani Ismael is mentioned in the hadith number since no Arabs live in the East????? Is there any explanation for this??

Arabs (Bani Ismael ) dont live in Khorasan

Hadith 12, 13,14,15,16,17 and 18 tells that armies helping Mahdi and Jesus will come from the Ancient Historical region of Khorasan and Arabs dont live in Khorasan .

How is it possible that Bani Ismael is mentioned in the hadith number since no Arabs live in the Khorasan?????

Arabs or Bani Ismael doesnt mean Bani Israel

Hadith 9,10 AND 11 tells that armies helping Mahdi and Jesus will be from BANI ISRAEL and AL E HAROON and Arabs or Bani Ismael are not from Bani Israel or Al e Haroon

MAY ALLAH SAVE US ALL FROM WRONG EXPLANATION OF AHADITH.

SOME SAY THAT BANI ISHAQ LIVE IN EUROPE

Prophet Ishaq had only one son i.e Propet Israel (Yaqoob) according to Quran and Hadith

According to Quran and Hadith Prophet Ishaq had only one son i.e Prophet Yaqoob (Israel) peace be upon them. Its only in the books of jews i.e the Torah which tells that Prophet Ishaq had another son by the name of ISU and this ISU is claimed to be the ancestor of the ROMANS.

Again AHadith 9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,177,18 tells that armies helping Mahdi and Jesus will come from the East and from the Ancient Historical region of Khorasan and also from Bani Israel and AL E HAROON

Are the ROMAN FROM THE EAST?

Are the Romans from Khorasan?

Are they from Bani Israel or Al e Haroon?

It is not possible that new Muslims from Europe will be among the Majority armies helping Imam Mahdi and Prophet Jesus (alayhay salam)

May Allah save us all from wrong explanations ameen (Allahuma salay ala Muhammad)

DID PROPHET ISHAQ (alayhay Salam) HAVE ANOTHER SON CALLED "ESU"

Lets do some research into the concept of Prophet Isaaq having a 2nd son by the name of ESU.

QURAN only tells us that Prophet Ishaq has only and only one son YAQOOB

سُوۡرَةُ آل عِمرَان

قُلۡ ءَامَنَّا بِٱللَّهِ وَمَآ أُنزِلَ عَلَيۡنَا وَمَآ أُنزِلَ عَلَىٰٓ إِبۡرَٲهِيمَ وَإِسۡمَـٰعِيلَ وَإِسۡحَـٰقَ وَيَعۡقُوبَ وَٱلۡأَسۡبَاطِ ....... (٨٤)

کہہ دو ہم الله پر ایمان لائے اور جو کچھ ہم پر نازل کیاگیا اور جو کچھ ابراھیم اور اسماعیل اور اسحاق اور یعقوب اور اس کی اولاد پر نازل کیا گیا

Say (O Muhammad SAW): "We believe in Allâh and in what has been sent down to us, and what was sent down to Ibrâhim (Abraham), Ismâ'il (Ishmael), Ishâq (Isaac), Ya'qûb (Jacob) and Al-Asbât [the offspring twelve sons of Ya'qûb (Jacob)]

Note : Some people are copying material from this website without permission. I do not allow them.Please do not copy without permission from Muhammad

at jonelya@gmail.com or jonelya@yahoo.com. Jazak Allahay Khairan

Why Quran is only mentioning one son of Ishaaq?q.??
Why Quran do mention two sons of Prophet Ibraheem but do not mention 2nd son of Prophet Ishaaq?q?
Why 12 sons of Prophet Jacob (Yaqoob) are mentioned but the 2nd son of Prophet Ishaaq is not mentioned?d?
So called Mr.Esu is missing here because he does not exist and only an untrustworthy narrator like
Ibn-e-Ishaq has mentioned him

Who spread this misconception for the first time in Islam?

This totally baseless concept of 2nd son of Prophet Ishaaq was spread by Mr Ibn-e-Ishaq.The Islamic world first came to know about this theory in 1030 AD in a book compile by Abu Rifa'a al Fasawl .In this book the claim is told by Al-Tha'labi. Mr Al-Tha'labi is totally depending only and only on the IBN ISHAQ narrator who is the most un trustworthy and weak narraotor and whose works are mostly rejected because of fabricated ahadith. Infact IBN ISHAQ is the only narrater who has said that Prophet Ishaq (alayhay salam) had a son called ISU or ESU and that ROMANS are the desendants of ESU . This is totally baseless and a theory of the Jewish books and has no authentic proof in the ahadith

---

Some people are copying material from this website without permission. I do not allow them.Please do not copy without permission from Muhammad at jonelya@gmail.com or jonelya@yahoo.com Jazak Allahay Khairan

This is is originately copied from http://armyofmahdi.googlepages.com/baniishaq